2012年1月8日星期日

White Vengeance/鸿门宴

We can see the director's ambition, but the movie still made the mistakes of regular Chinese movies, i.e., it wanted to stuff too many things into the movie: love, fate, brothers, life, chess-like destiny, war..., yet nothing was shown well. Too many clues confused the audience to highlight the real focus.

Besides, another comment, Pipa, as a musical instrument, was not introduced to China until the fifth century AD or later, not in the third century BC. The Pipa was a very important symbol in the movie, can't the director treat it more seriously?

可以猜到导演的野心,但本片仍然犯了国产电影的通病:想把太多的东西塞到片子里面去,什么都想讲,包括爱情、宿命、兄弟、人生、棋局、战争……,最后什么也没讲好。线索太多,反而没有让应该突出的重点得到突出。

再吐个槽,琵琶这种乐器是魏晋南北朝时期才传入中国的,不是在楚汉相争的时候就有了。这么一个重要的象征,麻烦也严肃一点对待历史好吧?

演职员印象:
导演:李仁港
编剧:李仁港
主演:黎明,冯绍峰,刘亦菲,张涵予,黄秋生,陈小春,丁海峰


Hong men yan chuan qi (2011) on IMDb

没有评论:

发表评论